In the Wake of D.C. Mayhem, the Role of Truth Tellers Is More Important Than Ever

By: Joyce Barnathan | 01/07/2021
Photo credit: Architect of the Capitol

We all may have thought that 2021 would be a more sane year after what we have been through in 2020. What happened Wednesday in Washington, D.C., made it clear that it isn’t. Throughout the past four years, many of us have worried when political leaders don’t honor truth (no less the U.S. Constitution). And now, we see the havoc that can happen when they don’t.

For me, this is the key lesson: We need to defend the truth. We need to communicate it better. If political leaders claim that elections were rigged, not on the basis of fact, but because they don’t like losing, they still influence their disaffected supporters who believe the lies. As Republican Senator Mitt Romney so eloquently put it: “The best way we can show respect for the voters who are upset is by telling them the truth.”

Journalism has a fundamental role to play in ensuring that the electorate understands deception and lies and disinformation. Yesterday shows that key swaths of the U.S. population no longer rely on legitimate journalistic sources for their information. It is urgent that those of us who believe in truth-telling—indeed, in democracy itself— support, defend and amplify the work of journalists in the U.S. and abroad, so that angry and ill-informed mobs don’t defile our Congress, or any parliament anywhere.

Empowering the truth tellers is so important this year. We need to ensure that journalists have the tools, training and resources to effectively communicate what’s really happening, and organizations like ICFJ can help them. Otherwise, reporters risk inadvertently purveying fictitious versions of reality spread by demagogues in elected office.

And while this may seem like exclusively a U.S. story, we know that the world is watching. Despots in countries without the safeguards we have in the United States have used the demagoguery they see here to justify their own. Through our work across the world, we have been humbled by journalists who have dealt with even worse assaults than what we saw yesterday. They have much to teach us.

I feel motivated—and not depressed—about the future. We can shape it, and I believe we will make it better by empowering people with trustworthy news.

 

 

Latest News

ICFJ Voices: Anubha Bhonsle on Delivering ‘News, Not Noise’

Anubha Bhonsle is an Indian journalist whose career has focused on developing new kinds of storytelling. Based in Delhi, Bhonsle has led groundbreaking initiatives related to gender and sanitation. She’s the founder of Newsworthy.Studio, and covers India, the Global South, current affairs, gender, climate adaptation and rights.

Exiled and Hybrid Media: Keeping Coverage Alive in Repressive States

This year’s World Press Freedom Day came at a time when free and unobstructed media is in turmoil with the rise of autocratic governments worldwide. In recent years, many journalists have had to flee their home countries and report for their communities from abroad – despite significant risks and hurdles.

How Leading International Editors are Responding to Information Pollution in a Pivotal Year for Democracy

At a panel during last month's International Journalism Festival in Perugia, Italy, Nobel Laureate Maria Ressa of the Philippines reminded us what’s at stake: AI often facilitates the spread of misinformation and disinformation, advancing authoritarian agendas.