Brazilian Men’s Magazine Analyzes Reader Comments to Prove its Vast Impact

By: ICFJ | 07/30/2019
ICFJ Knight Fellow Pedro Burgos speaks with a fellow panelist at ONA18.
ICFJ Knight Fellow Burgos (right) used his Impacto tool, finding 850 comments from readers saying that PapodeHomem helped them.
While online comments aren’t always known for civility, a digital men’s magazine in Brazil has used its comments section to build a thriving and supportive community that improves readers’ lives. Now, thanks to help from ICFJ Knight Fellow Pedro Burgos, the news outlet has the numbers to prove it.

Burgos analyzed 12 years of reader comments to examine Sao Paulo-based PapodeHomem’s impact on its community. The analysis identified at least 850 times that a reader said the site helped them, or even changed their lives. 

“Here I learned about relationships, masculinity, finances, health and well-being and many other subjects that helped me to grow up,” one user wrote. “Thanks to this community I am a better man, no doubt about it.”

Burgos analyzed the comments using Impacto, a platform he built with support from the Google News Initiative and further developed as an ICFJ Knight Fellow. Impacto uses automation to find instances of how journalism creates positive change. Through his fellowship, Burgos is pioneering new ways for news media to build trust among their audiences by showing the impact good journalism has on their lives and communities. 

The site also shared the results with readers, which Burgos says is critical. 

“We think that if newsrooms get better at collecting their impact, and communicating it to their audiences, it will strengthen trust in media and make a better case for why people should support journalism,” he said. 

To analyze the magazine’s impact on readers, Burgos and developer Bernardo Vianna worked with the magazine’s staff to create a list of metrics that indicate behavior change and gratitude in response to articles. Then, Impacto searched 226,000 comments posted on PapodeHomem’s website for those indicators. 

Nearly 20,000 comments, or one out of every 11, included a "thank you" or other expression of appreciation. 

“Impacto is helping us to better understand and show the world our value,” PapodeHomem founder Guilherme Valadares said. He noted that working with Burgos helped his team build a structured way of quantifying the magazine’s impact, something that they did not have before. “Clicks and views don't tell us how much we're impacting readers’ lives.”

PapodeHomem helps build this sense of online community by inviting conversation and encouraging multiple viewpoints, Burgos wrote in a blog post. Writers participate in the comments sections, making sure that discussions stay respectful, even on hot-button issues such as LGBT perspectives on Brazil’s election.

The journalists themselves are active members of the community. Guilherme commented 9,453 times. “They don’t let a big comment go without a reply from the editors,” Burgos said. In his blog post analyzing the comments, he invited additional feedback. The post received dozens of additional testimonials.

PapodeHomem also plans to use the data on comments to attract advertisers who are interested in connecting with a positive community.

Pedro Burgos is an ICFJ Knight Fellow based in São Paulo, Brazil. 

News Category
Country/Region

Latest News

Tips for Reporting on Gun Violence

During a recent ICFJ Global Crisis Reporting Forum webinar entitled “Gun Violence and How to Report on It,” Abené Clayton, a lead reporter for The Guardian U.S. series, Guns and Lies, which looks at community gun violence in California, provided tools and guidance on how journalists can improve their coverage. 

Disinformation Targeting U.S. Latino Communities is Widespread. Here's Why.

Did Spanish-language mis- and disinformation about the virus, which circulated largely unchecked, contribute to the high incidence of COVID-19 infection in Latino communities? Did social media play a role? Latino communities tend to use platforms like YouTube, Facebook and WhatsApp to inform themselves more than the average U.S. population, as they often don’t trust or feel represented by traditional media. 

The reality is, we know less about mis- and disinformation targeting Latino communities in the U.S. than we would like to, and there is almost no research on its impacts.    

ICFJ and The Self-Investigation launch "Resilience" Mental Health Program for Arabic-Speaking Journalists


To adopt healthier work practices that can sustain journalists' well-being, ICFJ is launching a new resilience program for Arabic-speaking journalists under the auspices of the ICFJ Pamela Howard Forum on Global Crisis Reporting. The initiative aims to shed light on the importance of mental health and well-being for workers in the media industry and provide crucial resources in Arabic for journalists. It kicks off October 10 to mark World Mental Health Day and will run through the end of November. You can register for the first session here.